Is There a Positive Correlation Between Acupuncture Treatments and Recovery of Cocaine Addicted Patients?
Question by Julie: Is there a positive correlation between acupuncture treatments and recovery of cocaine addicted patients?
[rewrite]Process of Science: Assume we have data indicating a strong positive correlation between acupuncture treatments and recovery of patients from, say, cocaine addiction. However, let’s also assume that every hypothesis we have for a mechanism of action (i.e., how acupuncture could work to help cure addiction) can be shown to be false. The patients, however, all claim to know that the acupuncture is what cured them. Which of the following conclusions are supported by our data?
Must acupuncture be responsible for the patients – recovery?
[/rewrite]
Best answer:
[rewrite]
Answer by Nate
No. If you can only show a correlation, and every investigated mechanism of action is false, you wouldn’t conclude that acupuncture is the cause of recovery.
Edit: Alties, this is a question of logic. If you only have correlation, it does not follow to conclude that acupuncture “must” be responsible.
Edit: “However, let’s also assume that every hypothesis we have for a mechanism of action (i.e., how acupuncture could work to help cure addiction) can be shown to be false.”
Did you miss this bit, Nosey?
Maybe people who seek help in overcoming cocaine addiction, whatever that help may be, are more likely to overcome it.
Answer by thenoseknows
Mechanism of action has historically not been used as a benchmark in medical studies, and a huge number of medical studies have been accepted without one —
About 80% of conventional drugs have unknown “mechanism of action”.
Surgery is not supported by randomized studies that can prove a mechanism of action either. It’s based on a hypothesis, trial and error. Then you have a statistical model of clinical experience.
So you will be left in a position that without any opposing evidence to the contrary that acupuncture was responsible for the patient’s recovery and that the mechanism of action was “unknown” as it is in plenty of other studies.
You will have a positive correlation between the acupuncture treatments and the patients recovery, and it will invariably create a situation whereby other researchers will duplicate your work or not.
Then some armchair critic with no scientific credentials will come along and claim your study was “inconclusive”.
[/rewrite]
Collaboration leads to crack down on heroin distribution ring
[rewrite]STEUBENVILLE – Jefferson County Prosecutor Jane Hanlin called federal and local indictments targeting 14 alleged drug dealers a huge step in fighting heroin sales and use in the Ohio Valley. … "Those charged include Lavinia Hearon, 29, of Chicago …[/rewrite]
Read more on Steubenville Herald Star
Toddler in heroin overdose case 'might have been saved'
[rewrite]The death of a toddler who took a fatal heroin overdose in the house where he lived with his drug-addicted parents in Wolverhampton might have been avoided if health and care workers had been more assertive, a report has said. … A post-mortem test on …[/rewrite]
Read more on Irish Independent
24 comments
[rewrite]We live in a surveillance state beyond the comprehension of the GDR's Stasi, or even the Spanish Inquisition's Edict of Faith, which demanded citizens spy on each other and report any trace of religious heresy to the Tribunal, including the use of …[/rewrite]
Read more on Drug WarRant
Cocaine Addiction: End Your Cocaine Addiction — http://www.encognitive.com Prokopton wrote: You cannot “think” or “group support” your way out of addiction because physiology is a strong component of subst…
Find More Cocaine Addiction Help Information…